Criticism of the CAGED System

Posted on Posted in Guitar, Guitar Lessons, Teaching

In guitar pedagogy, another method for teaching chords lies within the CAGED system. Essentially, this system helps organize chords. From this one could also organize arpeggios and scales as well. With five key open position chord shapes (C, A, G, E, D, hence CAGED), it allows a guitarist to play common chords up and down the neck.

For instance, take this C major chord shown below:

Ex. 1:

CAGED-C

 

 

 

 

Now to incorporate this into the CAGED system, we would change the fingering, as shown in Ex. 2:

Ex. 2:

CAGED-C-EX2

 

 

 

 

The 3rd finger is replaced by the 4th finger, the 2nd finger is replaced by the 3rd finger and the 1st finger is replaced by the 2nd finger. This leaves the 1st finger available to barre the G and higher-pitched E string. In Ex. 3, this shape moves up two frets while the first finger barres the G and higher-pitched E string, thus forming a D chord:

Ex. 3:

CAGED-D

 

 

 

 

Though beyond the scope of this post, the idea would be to take the other chord shapes and move it around to form other chords. All total, there are 60 chords to be found (five chords and twelve keys; 5 x 12 = 60).

My criticism of the easiness the CAGED system offers hinders long-term harmonic and analytical development. At face value, the CAGED system is not as effective in the long-term when learning about harmony. The main issue I see with this system is the tendency to merely memorize shapes, not sounds or note names. Just because someone can use this system to find a B chord does not mean that he or she will know that a basic B chord will comprise of the notes: B, D# and F#.

Though a longer route, guitar players should focus more on learning how to identify triads, seventh chords and hybrid chord inversions on all string groups. They should be able to play these chords closely and spread out. They should also voicelead these through progressions and other types of cycles (via 2nds, 4ths, 5ths, and the like). They also should think of creative and original ways to incorporate them into their vocabulary and know how to use voicings in multiple contexts. Though some may view the CAGED system a good way to organize and find chords (and sure, it might help out in the beginning), I recommend that guitar players concentrate more on the theory of how to construct and hear a chord up and down the fretboard. Using a piano is an invaluable tool.

Related Posts: Tablature and Traditional Music Notation

About Nick Grinlinton

Nick Grinlinton has written 113 entries on this blog.

Nick Grinlinton is a guitarist, composer and educator based in Brooklyn, NY. He is a two-time ASCAP Young Jazz Composer Award finalist and has composed and played music for Jerry Seinfeld's web series "Comedians in Cars Getting Coffee". A speedy runner, Nick currently focuses on racing distances from the mile all the way to the marathon. As he continues to train daily, he is currently examining what effect music has towards running. To learn more and to contact Nick, visit his website.

5 thoughts on “Criticism of the CAGED System

  1. I agree but guitar is a second instrument for me. I have a good understanding of harmony and the CAGED system got me started on the f re keyboard. I dont intend to stop there. The guitar is a incredibly interesting instrument. Where else can you play the same ( same frequency) 5 different places! Ties me up sometimes.

    1. Absolutely, Bob. It’s definitely a challenging instrument. After 22 years of playing, I’m finally able to start seeing some new things with it. It took me going to the piano to see the fretboard with different eyes.

  2. hi nick. thx for your remarks on the CAGED system. I disagree with you. the CAGED System if used properly – as in Fretboard Logic is a wonderful system to expand chord knowledge beyond the usual A and E form. Pick jazz players – usually they start with the A and E-shapes. more advanced then come the drop3 voicings. CAGED helped me to put it all together and really understand the system. The logic behind CAGED is: 5 forms as there are 6 strings but only 5 possible root notes. Espeacially the C-form and the G-Form offers so many ways to find alternative chord shapes with inversions.

    all the best

    Pablo

    1. Hey Pablo, thanks for reading my post. I actually had to re-read mine since it’s been almost 8 years since I wrote it. I’m happy to see that the system really helped you. Admittedly, my 33 year old self is probably a little more lax now than my 25 year old self. I will have to look into it again at some point.

      Take care,
      Nick

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *